Course Review Scorecard

A research-informed rubric for evaluating and enhancing online and blended course design and delivery.

A Trusted Tool for Improving Digital Learning

The OLC Course Review Scorecard is a comprehensive, evidence-based rubric used to evaluate the design, delivery, and overall effectiveness of online and blended courses. With 50 measurable objectives across three key categories, Essential Design, Advanced Design, and Course Delivery, the scorecard provides institutions and instructors with a reliable framework to promote continuous improvement and student-centered learning.

Why Course-Level Quality Matters

Individual course quality is a foundational building block for broader program success.

Courses that are well-designed, inclusive, and instructionally sound create more equitable and engaging experiences for learners. OLC’s Course Review Scorecard supports this by helping institutions assess and elevate the instructional design, accessibility, pedagogical approach, and delivery of their digital courses.

Ways to Use the Scorecard

The Course Review Scorecard is used by colleges and universities nationwide to:

  • Conduct internal faculty peer reviews or formalized institutional QA efforts
  • Guide self-assessment and reflection by instructors
  • Inform faculty development initiatives and instructional design practices
  • Capture and respond to student experience data
  • Participate in OLC’s Exemplary Course Review and Endorsement process

Courses that meet exemplary standards may qualify to display the official OLC Exemplary Course badge.

An accent image depicting a hand holding up a tablet displaying the front page of the Course Review Scorecard.

Download the Scorecard

The Course Review Scorecard is available as a free, open-access tool to support global efforts to improve online and blended learning. Institutions may adopt it as-is or adapt it to their internal quality assurance processes.

Additional Tools

The scorecard is available in both English and Spanish. OLC members gain access to additional tools and supports that guide implementation, faculty training, and review readiness, such as: 

  • Course Review Scorecard Handbook
  • Course Review Assistant GPT (with guide)
  • Peer Reviewer Guide
  • Course Review Transition Guide

Want Help Applying the Scorecard?

OLC offers expert-led Course Review Services to support your team in reviewing courses and strengthening instructional quality.

Get started with OLC Consulting

Please complete the form below.

We use cookies to enhance your experience. By continuing to visit this site you agree to our use of cookies. More info